'Are We Dating the Same Guy?': do Facebook groups harm or help?
Women share their relationship experiences to try to stay safe on dating apps but critics highlight legal and emotional issues
If you're a single woman who is dating, you probably know all about the "Are We Dating the Same Guy?" groups on Facebook.
The groups began in New York in 2022 to provide a private platform for women to share information about men and warn each other about deceit, infidelity and abuse, said Alexandra Arko on the legal news site JD Supra.
But what began as a city-specific safety collective has rapidly expanded. Now there are more than 200 group branches across the US and offshoots around the world, including one in London that has 90,000 members. Women share men's profiles from dating apps and ask for information, while others respond with personal anecdotes, screenshots of interactions or public information like criminal records.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
The Los Angeles branch (about 52,000 members) has now become embroiled in a $2.6 million lawsuit. One man, Stewart Lucas Murrey, is suing a woman who claimed that (after matching on a dating app) the pair had had a phone conversation in 2022 – during which Murrey was "rude", said The Times. Murrey is also suing more than 50 other members who responded with their own claims about him, alleging they "ruined his love life, damaged his reputation and cost him millions in missed job opportunities". The lawsuit also accuses the women of discrimination, because Murrey was unable to join the women-only group and defend himself.
'The internet is forever'
This is not the first time a man has sued posters in a branch of AWDTSG, said Arko. A "private" Facebook group is not private in the eyes of the law, and the First Amendment right to free speech in the US is "not absolute". Men "often have legal claims against the posters" for defamation, harassment or invasion of privacy.
Volunteer moderators have strict rules – members cannot post addresses or identifying information beyond a first name – but this offers members "a false sense of security". Anonymity is also a delusion, as courts "frequently" order social media platforms like Meta to hand over a user's identity. Deleting a post does not prevent the subject from suing, either. After all, "the internet is forever".
The tone of these groups is often "petty", said dating coach Sera Bozza in Body+Soul, with men "ridiculed for appearances". But even "lurkers" who don't post should tread carefully, she wrote, after joining a Sydney-based 30,000-member group.
There is "a more profound consequence" than legal or bullying issues. Being "bombarded with stories of dating disasters", amplified by the "drama-loving algorithm", can increase cynicism and breed mistrust. It may persuade users that "all men are unfaithful" – seldom true and hardly empowering.
'Women talking to each other is not the problem'
"The more I looked at the group, the more I noticed myself feeling less and less inclined to even try to meet someone," said Kate Solomon in The Independent.
But the fact is, "dating apps come with a good deal of risk". These groups have helped many women uncover cat-fishing, conmen and "serial ghosters".
Add that to the reality that almost a third of women aged 15-49 worldwide will be sexually or physically abused – and that's to say nothing of emotional abuse, far harder to quantify – and it's "no wonder we want to sense-check every little detail when we connect with a stranger". Ultimately, "women talking to each other is not the problem: the culture that makes it easy to behave badly is".
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Harriet Marsden is a writer for The Week, mostly covering UK and global news and politics. Before joining the site, she was a freelance journalist for seven years, specialising in social affairs, gender equality and culture. She worked for The Guardian, The Times and The Independent, and regularly contributed articles to The Sunday Times, The Telegraph, The New Statesman, Tortoise Media and Metro, as well as appearing on BBC Radio London, Times Radio and “Woman’s Hour”. She has a master’s in international journalism from City University, London, and was awarded the "journalist-at-large" fellowship by the Local Trust charity in 2021.
-
Today's political cartoons - September 28, 2024
Cartoons Saturday's cartoons - same old story, scaredy cat, and more
By The Week US Published
-
5 scandalously funny cartoons about Mark Robinson
Cartoons Artists take on political exposure, a Hindenburg moment, and more
By The Week US Published
-
His Three Daughters: 'sharply written' family drama is 'deeply affecting'
The Week Recommends 'Absorbing' film about three estranged sisters caring for their dying father in New York
By The Week UK Published
-
From 'Teenage Dream' to millennial nightmare – where did it go wrong for Katy Perry?
Talking Point Brutal reviews for new album represent a serious setback in the pop star's attempted return
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
'Wuthering Heights' and the Robbie-Elordi casting row
Talking Point The casting of Barbie and Elvis is 'fundamentally, egregiously wrong' in Emerald Fennell's new film
By The Week UK Published
-
Turner Prize 2024: has the art world's infamous award lost its power?
Talking Point As the award returns for its 40th anniversary, critics call for a revamp of 'sorry embarrassment of a prize'
By Irenie Forshaw, The Week UK Published
-
'Beast' of a lawsuit: YouTube star and Amazon sued by contestants over abuse claims
The Explainer Can the breakout YouTube star weather a growing scandal engulfing his forthcoming reality TV competition?
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US Published
-
Lee: Kate Winslet biopic lacks 'nuance that made Miller exceptional'
Talking Point Winslet fought to get the film made, but critics are divided on whether it lives up to expectations
By The Week UK Published
-
A Very Royal Scandal: more trouble for the royals?
Talking Point Amazon Prime's new Prince Andrew drama could be another headache for the royal family
By The Week UK Published
-
Beetlejuice Beetlejuice: pure 'nostalgia bait'
Talking Point Michael Keaton and Winona Ryder return for sequel to the 1988 cult classic
By The Week UK Published
-
Maria: has Angelina Jolie biopic missed the mark?
Talking Point Pablo Larraín creates an engaging love letter to Callas in "Maria"
By The Week Staff Published